Raphael Patai writes of sensitive human subjects and behavior in a way . Raphael Patai’s The Arab Mind is a “field tested” book—and I mean. The book in question is called The Arab Mind, and is by Raphael Patai, a cultural anthropologist who taught at several US universities. Hersh also made reference to a book, The Arab Mind, by the cultural anthropologist Raphael Patai (). The notion that Arabs are particularly vulnerable.
| Author: | Vudom Mikarr |
| Country: | Fiji |
| Language: | English (Spanish) |
| Genre: | Career |
| Published (Last): | 2 April 2012 |
| Pages: | 104 |
| PDF File Size: | 6.29 Mb |
| ePub File Size: | 6.80 Mb |
| ISBN: | 355-3-86019-901-8 |
| Downloads: | 2832 |
| Price: | Free* [*Free Regsitration Required] |
| Uploader: | Kigar |
The book is not actually about Africans. I can go on and on and on. It globs together hundreds of millions of people in a series of cliches and distortions.
The book in question is called The Arab Mind, and is by Raphael Patai, a cultural anthropologist who taught at several US universities, including Columbia and Princeton. The CIA is particularly interested in information about imminent or planned terrorist attacks.
A very unscientific, biased and full-of-lies-book. The book was described by The Guardian correspondent Brian Whitaker as one that presents “an overwhelmingly negative picture of the Arabs. It is written by a non-Arab who has spent his lifetime studying the Arabic language and culture. In contrast, opinions of Patai’s book among Middle East experts at US universities are almost universally scathing.
‘Its best use is as a doorstop’
This book has been recognized as one of the seminal works in the field of Middle Arrab studies. But that’s enough for this point.
This book is not for entertainment, but it kept me engrossed. Questions like why Western colonists are hated so much more than the Ottomons who colonized all of the Arab countries far longer, the Arab relationship with modernity, its treatment of women, episodes of sudden and inexplicable emotional outbursts are mine covered by numerous examples from arabic literature. Viewed against these two general categories of national character research, The Arab Mind belongs more to the earlier than the later tradition of research in this field.
Pre-Islam Bedouins used to bury their daughters, i don’t see that happen now. We do not routinely respond to questions for which answers are found within this Web site. Majd rated it liked it Sep 02, This book became a standard text for American foreign service employees after it came out in the s and is responsible for distorting America’s relationship with the Arab world.
He lived for decades in Jerusalem pre-Israel. None of the academics I contacted thought the book suitable for serious study, although Georgetown University once invited students to analyse it as “an example of bad, biased social science”. If the book was about any other ethnic group, African Americans, Roman Catholics, Latinos, there would be a thousand condemnations. Jul 13, Natassia rated it really liked it. No trivia or quizzes yet. Books by Raphael Patai.
I’d say this is one of the few books I’ve seen written about Arabs by a non-Arab person, but in a fair and well explained manner.
Writing about Arabs, rather than black people, in these terms ptai makes all the difference between a racist smear and an admirable work of scholarship.
This book is about Arab culture. Perhaps it is now time he turned his attention to military schools in the US. May 23, Janna rated it it was amazing. This was particularly true of the Iraqi women with whom I worked in Baghdad from June to January In their discussions, he said, two themes emerged – ‘one, that Arabs only understand force, and two, that the biggest weakness of Arabs is mond and humiliation’.
Then the adults told us in Arabic and gestured to us to shoot the children. Controversial and scathing in parts, this book should be read with caution and balanced by other study. Patai also addresses what to Westerners are obscure points like what is apparently a very large and very important cultural difference between Arabs from the north and south of the Arabian peninsula, so-called dual descent, either Qays or Yaman.
This page was last edited on 18 Juneat Moreover, his adherence to this framework throughout his book is, indeed, impressive. For my part pafai am 29 and i have never had sex before, not even a kiss because i want to mnid married and see that later, also i make sure that none of my two sisters does anything like that, and the best thing is that i don’t have to give them advice as they know that it’s in their best interest.
The Arab Mind – Wikipedia
The Arab Mind discusses the upbringing of a typical Arab boy or Since its original publication inthe revised edition of Raphael Patai’s The Kind Mind has been recognized as one of the minv works in the field of Middle Eastern studies.
Learned that features of the language many fewer verb raab than in English impact the way they think, speak, and are interpreted. While Hamady and Patai reach many of the same conclusions about the Arabs, Patai’s analysis and explanation of the “why” of their behavior places his study on a considerably higher analytical plane than that of Mine.
Patai exhaustively demonstrates that Arabs themselves have always held that there is a common Arab approach to some things as any culture hasfor example: The Arab mind Close. It clears up a few things but it also makes me realize how far apart our thinking is. Now for God’s sake who would believe such crap? If you need a respected un-biased book on Muslims and of course Arab Mind, Check Graham Fuller’s “A World without Islam” it explains nearly everything on the subject and the best thing is that it was written by a man who studied Middle-East and Islam and worked for the CIA as an adviser, so he knows what he nind about.
Patai’s book is clearly the product of a profound knowledge of Patsi civilization. Patai died inbut his book was revived by Hatherleigh Press in nicely timed for the war in Iraqand reprinted with an enthusiastic introduction by Norvell “Tex” De Atkine, a former US army colonel and the head of Middle East studies at Fort Bragg.
The Arab Mind
All this adds up to an overwhelmingly negative picture of the Arabs. To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up. Lists with This Book. In this respect, it is appropriate to compare Patai’s book with Sania Hamady’s The Temperament and Character of the Arabspublished insince the objective of both authors was the same — the delineation of Arab national character. But the well-researched national character dimension combined with other relevant variables appears to hold considerable potential for improving the assessment of the propensity of a mid, elite, or electorate to act in certain directions.
Last edited by Mek.
Patai is criticized in passing at several points in Edward Said ‘s book Orientalism. We are also informed page of “the Arab view that masturbation is far more shameful than visiting prostitutes”. These statements, I think you’ll agree, are thoroughly offensive. Served in Gaza mnid Sinai.
